top of page

Before the Ghosts: What "Gothic" Meant to the Victorians

Oct 19
8 min read

On the evening of October 16, 1834, workmen at the Palace of Westminster fed two cartloads of old wooden tally sticks into the furnaces beneath the House of Lords. By nightfall the medieval palace was burning. Crowds packed the bridges and riverbanks to watch, and by morning most of the seat of British government was gone.



What rose in its place took thirty years to build, and it was Gothic: pointed windows, carved stone tracery, a forest of pinnacles along the Thames, and a clock tower the world now calls Big Ben. To the Victorians who built it, Gothic was the most dignified, the most English, even the most Christian way a building could look.


Ghosts were the last thing on their minds.


The entry


The Victorians' own dictionaries make the point plainly. Here is the word in Webster's dictionary of 1828, nine years before Victoria took the throne:


GOTH'IC, adjective. Pertaining to the Goths; as gothic customs; gothic architecture; gothic barbarity. 1. Rude; ancient. 2. Barbarous.


Architecture is there only as an example, sitting beside "barbarity." By the 1913 edition of Webster's, it had earned a full, admiring sense of its own: "a style of architecture with pointed arches, steep roofs, windows large in proportion to the wall spaces, and, generally, great height in proportion to the other dimensions."


The British Chambers's dictionary of 1901, published the year the queen died, gathers the whole century into a single entry: "belonging to the Goths or their language: barbarous: romantic: denoting a style of architecture with high-pointed arches, clustered columns, &c."


Barbarous. Romantic. Pointed arches. Not one of these entries mentions a ghost, a vampire, or a novel. How did the word get from there to here?


An insult


It begins with the Goths themselves, the Germanic peoples who overran the Roman Empire, and who had nothing whatever to do with pointed arches. The great cathedrals of the Middle Ages were built centuries after the Gothic kingdoms had faded from Western Europe. The people who built them called the style "French work," or simply "modern work."


The name Gothic came later, and it began as an insult. To the scholars and artists of the Italian Renaissance, who prized the columns and proportions of ancient Rome, medieval building looked crude. Giorgio Vasari, writing his Lives of the Artists in 1550, dismissed it as a barbarous German style. "Gothic" became the name for it, and the name was meant to sting. It meant the work of barbarians, the opposite of civilization.


That is the sense Webster was still printing in 1828: rude, ancient, barbarous.


A castle at Twickenham


The word began to soften in the eighteenth century, in the hands of an English gentleman with a taste for the old and the strange. In 1747 Horace Walpole took a small house at Twickenham, on the Thames above London, and two years later he began turning it into what he called his "little Gothic castle." Strawberry Hill grew battlements, pointed windows, fan-vaulted ceilings and painted glass. It was medieval as a stage set is medieval, but it was a sensation, and people came to see it.


One morning in June of 1764, Walpole woke from a dream. As he later wrote to a friend, he had thought himself "in an ancient castle (a very natural dream for a head filled like mine with Gothic story)," and on the uppermost banister of a great staircase he had seen a gigantic hand in armor. He sat down that evening and began to write.


The result was The Castle of Otranto, published on Christmas Eve of 1764. Walpole disguised it as a translation of an Italian manuscript printed in Naples in 1529. When it sold, he admitted he had written it, and the second edition of 1765 carried a new subtitle: A Gothic Story.


So one of the most influential Gothic houses and the very first Gothic novel came from the same man, within a few years of each other. Architecture and literature met at Strawberry Hill. The novels that followed, with their castles, crypts and imprisoned heroines, were Gothic because they were set in the barbarous, haunted past. The architecture came first. The ghosts came with it.


The Christian style


But for the Victorians, the ghosts could wait. To them, Gothic was serious: a matter of faith, and of how a nation ought to build.


In 1836, two years after the fire, a young architect named Augustus Welby Pugin published a book called Contrasts. Through drawings of medieval and modern buildings, he argued that England had lost something precious. In a revised edition of 1841, he set a noble medieval town beside the same town four hundred years later, its skyline crowded with factories, a workhouse and a jail. Pugin had recently converted to Catholicism, and he believed that Gothic was the true Christian architecture, while the classical styles of Greece and Rome belonged to a pagan past. In 1841 he set the argument out again in The True Principles of Pointed or Christian Architecture.


Pugin worked alongside Charles Barry, who won the competition to rebuild Westminster. Barry gave the building its shape, and Pugin gave it its Gothic soul: the carving, the tiles, the wallpapers, the furniture, even the door handles, and in 1852 the design of the great clock tower. When we picture a Victorian Gothic building, we are very often picturing Pugin's.


Gothic for everyone


Then came John Ruskin, the most widely read critic of his age. In The Stones of Venice, published between 1851 and 1853, he included a chapter called "The Nature of Gothic." Gothic was beautiful, Ruskin argued, because it was made by free workmen. Every carved leaf and grotesque face was the work of a man allowed to think as he worked, rather than a machine-made copy. A rough Gothic carving was more honest than a perfect classical one.


With Pugin's faith and Ruskin's morals behind it, Gothic spread everywhere. It went into churches, of course, but also into town halls, schools, colleges, banks and railway stations. At St Pancras in London, George Gilbert Scott designed a railway hotel like a red-brick cathedral, its towers and pointed arches rising above the busy station. Travelers arrived not merely at a terminus, but at a monument to the Gothic Revival. To a Victorian, Gothic was the style of progress dressed in the clothes of faith. It was respectable, modern, and everywhere.


Gothic in America


The style crossed the Atlantic, and Americans made it their own in wood.


In the 1840s the landscape designer Andrew Jackson Downing and the architect Alexander Jackson Davis published pattern books of house designs, beginning with Cottage Residences in 1842 and followed by Downing's The Architecture of Country Houses in 1850. They offered ordinary families plans for cottages with steep gables, pointed windows and deep, decorated eaves. Then the steam-powered scroll saw made it cheap to cut wooden trim in any shape a builder could draw, and the lacy bargeboards and "gingerbread" porches of what we now call Carpenter Gothic went up in towns and on farms across the country. Gothic, once the style of cathedrals, had come home to the front porch.


The most famous of these houses stands in Eldon, Iowa. It was built around 1881, a plain white farmhouse with one pointed window in its gable. In 1930 the painter Grant Wood saw it, painted a stern farmer and his daughter in front of it, and called the picture American Gothic. The "Gothic" in the most famous American painting of the century is that one Victorian window.


The ghosts arrive


Meanwhile, the Gothic story had never quite gone away. It had changed its address.


The old Gothic novels had set their terrors in faraway castles and the distant past. Victorian writers brought those terrors closer, into family relationships and familiar city streets. In Sheridan Le Fanu's Carmilla, serialized in 1871 and 1872, the danger arrives as a guest welcomed into the family home. Robert Louis Stevenson's Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde, in 1886, finds its monster behind the door of a respectable London doctor. Bram Stoker's Dracula, in 1897, brings the count to London, and the men who hunt him use the newest inventions of the age: trains, telegrams and typewriters.


These stories were thrilling, and the Victorians devoured them, along with the ghost stories their magazines published every Christmas. Gothic was already a name for a kind of fiction, but readers did not necessarily use it for every vampire tale or haunted house. It was later critics who gathered many of these works together as Victorian Gothic, and in doing so gave the old word its broadest meaning yet.


Three things called Gothic


So when we say "Victorian Gothic" today, we are usually blending three separate things.


The first is mourning. When Prince Albert died in December of 1861, Queen Victoria put on black and wore mourning for the rest of her life, nearly forty years. Mourning customs were already deeply rooted, but the queen's example reinforced them, and crape, jet, veils and elaborate rules for grief became the picture we now hold of the Victorian woman in black.


The second is the fiction: the vampires, the doubles and the haunted houses.


The third arrived a century later. In 1979, a Manchester record producer described the band Joy Division as "Gothic," and the music press took up the word. British post-punk bands such as Bauhaus and Siouxsie and the Banshees were making dark, dramatic music, and by the early 1980s London clubs like the Batcave had helped give a new subculture its recognizable style. Goth fashion drew on Victorian mourning dress, Gothic fiction, punk and theatrical horror, and the borrowing has been so successful that the three now seem like one.


Each is real. But none of them is what a Victorian meant when he called a building Gothic.


Looking up this autumn


Next time you pass an old church, a railway station or a farmhouse with a pointed window in its gable, look up. That window was not built to frighten anyone. Whoever built it may have thought it beautiful, honest, dignified, or even a little closer to God. Then go home, pull the curtains and read a ghost story by the fire. The Victorians would have approved of both.


Watch



From the shop

Carmilla Sweatshirt | Le Fanu Gothic Vampire Crewneck, Victorian Portrait
Buy Now

Macabre Dictionary Sweatshirt | Victorian Engraving Crewneck
Buy Now

Sources

Webster, Noah. An American Dictionary of the English Language, 1828: "Gothic." https://webstersdictionary1828.com/Dictionary/gothic


Webster's Revised Unabridged Dictionary, 1913: "Gothic." https://websters1913.timcieplowski.com/word/gothic/


Chambers's Twentieth Century Dictionary, 1901, E–M (Project Gutenberg): "Goth." https://www.gutenberg.org/files/38538/38538-h/38538-h.htm





Chapuis, Julien. "Gothic Art." The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 2002. https://www.metmuseum.org/essays/gothic-art



Lindfield, Peter. "Heraldry and the Architectural Imagination: John Carter's Visualisation of The Castle of Otranto." The Antiquaries Journal (quoting Walpole's letter to William Cole, March 9, 1765). https://www.storre.stir.ac.uk/bitstream/1893/24032/1/AJ%2096%20Lindfield%20Otranto%20PNL.pdf


Walpole, Horace. The Castle of Otranto (Project Gutenberg). https://gutenberg.org/files/696/696-h/696-h.htm


The Victorian Web. "Pugin's Contrasts and Isaac Williams." https://victorianweb.org/victorian/art/architecture/pugin/williams.html


Ruskin, John. The Stones of Venice, Volume II (Project Gutenberg). https://gutenberg.org/files/30755/30755-h/30755-h.htm


Historic England. "St Pancras Station and Former Midland Grand Hotel," List Entry 1342037. https://historicengland.org.uk/listing/the-list/list-entry/1342037



History Colorado. "Carpenter Gothic." https://www.historycolorado.org/carpenter-gothic


The Metropolitan Museum of Art. Downing, The Architecture of Country Houses, 1850. https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/348831


Art Institute of Chicago. Grant Wood, American Gothic, 1930. https://www.artic.edu/artworks/6565/american-gothic


State Historical Society of Iowa. "American Gothic House." https://history.iowa.gov/media/269/download


Corpus of Electronic Texts, University College Cork. Le Fanu, Carmilla. https://celt.ucc.ie/published/E870000-005/header.html


The Metropolitan Museum of Art. Mourning dress (catalogue entry on Victorian mourning). https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/155839


Museum of Youth Culture. "Goth." https://www.museumofyouthculture.com/goth/


The Museum at FIT. Gothic: Dark Glamour, curated by Valerie Steele, 2008–2009. https://www.fitnyc.edu/museum/exhibitions/gothic-dark-glamour.php

bottom of page