Flowers in the Summer, Fires in the Fall: Robert Louis Stevenson’s “Autumn Fires”
The Children’s Hour
In autumn, the gardens of a Victorian town smoked. Once the last flowers were done, the stalks were pulled, the fallen leaves were raked into heaps, and everything was burned where it lay. At dusk the smoke drifted over the garden walls and hung in the lanes, and anyone walking home could see a dozen thin gray columns rising from back gardens all the way up the valley.

A child once stood at a window and watched them, or so the poem would have us believe. The child was Robert Louis Stevenson, or rather the boy he remembered being, and the poem is “Autumn Fires,” twelve short lines from A Child’s Garden of Verses.
A sick child in Edinburgh
Stevenson was born in Edinburgh in 1850, the only child of a family of lighthouse engineers, and he was ill for much of his boyhood. Coughs and fevers kept him in bed for weeks at a time. The person who nursed him through them was Alison Cunningham, whom he called Cummy. She sat up with him through long nights, told him stories and read to him.
When he was well, he was often sent to his grandfather’s manse at Colinton, on the edge of the city, where he played in the garden with a crowd of cousins. Looking back, he named three powerful impressions of his childhood: his sufferings when he was sick, his delights in getting well at Colinton, and the restless activity of his mind once he was put to bed at night. Nearly all of A Child’s Garden of Verses grows out of those three things.
The summer of the island
In August 1881 Stevenson was thirty, married, still unwell, and not yet famous. He took a cottage at Braemar in the Highlands with his wife, his stepson and his parents. It rained without stopping. To pass the time with his twelve-year-old stepson, he drew and painted a map of an imaginary island, and out of that map came Treasure Island.
That same wet summer, someone in the house had a copy of Kate Greenaway’s Birthday Book for Children. This was a small, very popular 1880 gift book, with Greenaway’s drawings of children for every day of the year and a short rhyme to go with each. The verses were by a children’s writer named Mrs. Sale Barker. Stevenson read them, decided that rhymes like these couldn’t be very hard to write, and set out to see whether he could do as well.
From Penny Whistles to a garden
He kept at the verses for the next two years, mostly in sickrooms. By March 1883, at Hyères on the south coast of France, he had about 48 pieces. The working title changed several times, from Nursery Verses to The Jews’ Harp to Penny Whistles. He hoped one of the great picture-book artists of the day, Walter Crane, Kate Greenaway or Randolph Caldecott, would illustrate it.
None of them did. When Longmans, Green and Co. published the book in London in 1885, it had no pictures at all and a new name, A Child’s Garden of Verses. It opened with a dedication to Cummy, “from her boy.” The first illustrated edition, with drawings by Charles Robinson, appeared in 1895, the year after Stevenson died in Samoa. Since then the book has hardly ever been out of print, and illustrators have taken it up agan and again.
What made it new was its point of view. Most children’s verse of the time was written to children, usually to teach them something. Stevenson wrote as a child, from the inside: the injustice of going to bed while it’s still light in summer, a shadow that grows and shrinks in ways no one can explain, a bed that becomes a boat.
Garden Days
The book is arranged in sections, and “Autumn Fires” belongs to Garden Days, a group of eight poems about the flowers, birds, and seasons of a garden. It is the sixth in the group, and it’s where the garden year ends.
The poem moves in three steps. First, the child looks outward, past his own garden to the others, and sees the smoke trailing up the vale. Second, he says what it means: summer and all its flowers are over, and the fire is burning what’s left. Third, instead of mourning, he turns it into a song. Every season has something bright in it. Summer had flowers, and fall has fires.
It’s a short poem with a grown-up idea in it, offered with a child’s confidence: loss and consolation can arrive in the same moment.
Stevenson wrote many of these poems while he was ill in bed, and he lived with serious lung illness for most of his life. So the cheerful last stanza, which finds something bright in every season, came from a man who had spent long stretches not knowing whether he would get well.
The idea didn’t escape his early readers either. When an American publisher issued the book as a school reader for the primary grades in 1919, the editors left out the whole Garden Days section, along with two others, because they judged many of those poems too philosophical for young children. “Autumn Fires” is simple on the surface and deeper than it looks.
Reading it with children
“Autumn Fires” is short enough to learn by heart in a week, which is how many children once met poems like it. Read it aloud a few times over several days, and let your child join in on the last stanza first, since its rhymes carry it. The whole poem makes a good copywork passage. If you have a garden, or a neighbor burning leaves, stand outside at dusk and look for the smoke.
Autumn Fires
Robert Louis Stevenson, from A Child’s Garden of Verses (1885)
In the other gardens
And all up the vale,
From the autumn bonfires
See the smoke trail!
Pleasant summer over
And all the summer flowers,
The red fire blazes,
The grey smoke towers.
Sing a song of seasons!
Something bright in all!
Flowers in the summer,
Fires in the fall!
Watch
Sources
Britannica, “A Child’s Garden of Verses”: https://www.britannica.com/topic/A-Childs-Garden-of-Verses
David Brass Rare Books, catalog note on the 1885 first edition (Braemar, 1881; the Greenaway birthday book; the 48 poems): https://www.biblio.com/book/childs-garden-verses-stevenson-robert-louis/d/1707614698
J. R. Hammond, A Robert Louis Stevenson Companion, chapter on Treasure Island (Braemar, summer 1881): https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-1-349-06080-1_6
Christy DiFrances Remein, “Stevenson’s sick children: A Child’s Garden of Verses and the therapeutic imagination,” Archives of Disease in Childhood: https://adc.bmj.com/content/106/7/725
National Library of Scotland, on Colinton and Swanston in the poems: https://digital.nls.uk/rlstevenson/pics/picture-j5.html
Bauman Rare Books, on Kate Greenaway’s Birthday Book for Children (1880): https://baumanrarebooks.com/authors/Kate-GREENAWAY/206477
A Child’s Garden of Verses, 1919 school reader edition with its editors’ introduction, Project Gutenberg: https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/25617
A Child’s Garden of Verses, illustrated by Charles Robinson (1895), Project Gutenberg: https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/25610

