A Gothic Evening: The Vicarage, the Study and the Music They Loved
When I set out to make a Gothic ambiance video, I became curious about where the word came from. Today “Gothic” evokes ghosts, cobwebs, and candlelit shadows, and I love that world as much as anyone. But as I wrote in Before the Ghosts, the word meant something rather different to the architects and reformers of the Gothic Revival. To them, Gothic meant the pointed arch, the stained-glass window and the parish church. It expressed a serious, often devout longing for the medieval past. I wanted to spend an evening in that older Gothic world and see what it might tell us about how the Victorians lived, with every detail chosen to belong there.

The house by the church
The video opens on a vicarage at dusk, standing beside its old church. It’s built in the style historians call High Victorian Gothic: red brick laid in bands and patterns of darker brick, steep roofs, tall clustered chimneys and pointed windows. Architects like William Butterfield and George Edmund Street made this patterned brickwork their signature in the 1850s and 1860s. They also designed parsonages to sit beside the churches they built or restored. The Church of England built and rebuilt at a remarkable pace in those decades. English Heritage counts 2,438 churches built or rebuilt between 1851 and 1875, and some new parsonages were built in the latest Gothic style.
At the churchyard entrance stands a lych-gate. It’s a small roofed gateway where a coffin rested on its way in, waiting for the clergyman to meet it. The word comes from the Old English lic, meaning corpse. The Victorians restored old lych-gates and built many new ones. The dark, upright trees are Irish yews, a column-shaped variety that became popular in Victorian churchyards. Yews had stood in English churchyards for centuries, and the Victorians continued the tradition.
The study
Inside, we’re in the vicar’s study, furnished the way A.W.N. Pugin taught a generation to furnish. Pugin was the great champion of the Gothic Revival. In his writings of the 1830s and 1840s, he argued that Gothic was the only honest, truly Christian style. He designed furniture to match his buildings: solid carved oak, pointed arches, tracery panels, and nothing applied just for show. Pugin’s ideas spread from churches into private homes. Though he was a Roman Catholic himself, his designs shaped Anglican taste as well. A study furnished in his Gothic manner would have been entirely at home in a Victorian vicarage.
The fire is coal, burning in an iron grate, as it would have in countless Victorian homes. The lamp is a paraffin lamp, which came into wide use in the 1860s as a brighter, cheaper light than candles. Candles still stand in brass Gothic candlesticks, as they would in a room between eras. Against the wall is a harmonium, the small reed organ found in countless Victorian homes and village churches. Rain runs down a traceried window, and a black cat has claimed the chair by the fire.
The music
I took the most care with the music. I wanted the music to belong to the Victorian world, whether it was an older work they cherished or something composed during Victoria’s reign.
Felix Mendelssohn was perhaps the most beloved composer in Victorian England. He played for Victoria and Albert at Buckingham Palace, and the Queen sang his songs. The Adagio in this video comes from the string quartet he wrote in 1847 after his sister Fanny's sudden death. He died himself only months later. It’s one of his most grief-stricken works, and it suits a quiet study on a rainy night.
The Victorians also rediscovered Bach. Mendelssohn had revived the St. Matthew Passion in Berlin in 1829. A Bach Society was founded in London in 1849, and the Passion had its first English performance a few years later. Musicians had never lost Bach’s keyboard and organ music, but his great sacred works had largely disappeared from public performance. Seeing them studied and performed again shared something with the Gothic Revival itself.
Liszt’s Bénédiction de Dieu dans la solitude, published in 1853, is a long prayer set to music, written after a poem by Lamartine. Schubert’s Death and the Maiden takes its name from his earlier song, in which Death comes to a frightened young woman. The image traces back to Renaissance art and, earlier, to the medieval Dance of Death. Mozart’s Requiem premiered in London in 1801 and became a fixture of the concert hall in the decades that followed.
The later pieces come from the Victorian decades themselves. England adored Dvořák in the 1880s. He conducted his Stabat Mater in London in 1884, and his Poetic Tone Pictures, including “At the Old Castle,” followed in 1889. Fauré wrote the song Après un rêve in the 1870s. Saint-Saëns finished his first string quartet in 1899, just before the century turned.
Most of these pieces are played in the video as piano or string arrangements, and that, too, has a Victorian precedent. Before recorded music, middle-class families often learned orchestral and chamber works through parlor-piano arrangements. Publishers sold reductions of symphonies, quartets, and sacred music so people could bring a little of the concert hall home. People could play a piece heard once in concert again and again by the fireside.
Keep the lamps low
The video runs just under an hour. It’s meant for reading, writing, or simply sitting with a cup of tea while the rain comes down. You’ll find it linked below or on the K.B. Hall Home YouTube channel in the Victorian Evenings playlist. If you’d like to learn more about what the Victorians meant by “Gothic,” start with “Before the Ghosts ” here in the Journal.
Keep the lamps low.
Watch
Sources
The house by the church
English Heritage. "Religion in Victorian England."
Street, George Edmund. Brick and Marble in the Middle Ages: Notes of a Tour in the North of Italy. London: John Murray, 1855.
Encyclopaedia Britannica, 11th ed. (1911). "Lych-gate."
National Botanic Gardens of Ireland. On the Irish yew, Taxus baccata 'Fastigiata'.
The study
Pugin, A.W.N. Contrasts. London, 1836.
Pugin, A.W.N. The True Principles of Pointed or Christian Architecture. London: John Weale, 1841.
Historic England. "A.W.N. Pugin."
The Metropolitan Museum of Art. On the furniture of A.W.N. Pugin.
The Building Conservation Directory. "Lighting in the Victorian Home."
University of Southampton. Sounding Erddig: the Erddig harmonium.
The music
Grove, George, ed. A Dictionary of Music and Musicians. London: Macmillan, 1879–1889. "Bach Society."
Mendelssohn Bartholdy, Felix. Letters, including his account of playing for Queen Victoria and Prince Albert at Buckingham Palace, 1842.
The National Gallery, London. On the Death and the Maiden tradition.
Antonín Dvořák (antonin-dvorak.cz). Stabat Mater; Poetic Tone Pictures, Op. 85.
G. Henle Verlag. Liszt, Harmonies poétiques et religieuses; notes on nineteenth-century piano arrangements.
Daub, Adrian. Four-Handed Monsters: Four-Hand Piano Playing and Nineteenth-Century Culture. New York: Oxford University Press, 2014.
Bibliothèque nationale de France. Fauré, Après un rêve, Op. 7, No. 1.
Palazzetto Bru Zane (bruzanemediabase.com). Saint-Saëns, String Quartet No. 1, Op. 112.
Music in the video: recordings courtesy of www.classicals.de


