top of page

The Truth, the Whole Truth: Rhoda Broughton’s Ghost Story in Letters

Oct 24
3 min read

In May, a woman named Bessy De Wynt finds the perfect Mayfair house for her dearest friend. It is pretty, fresh and clean, hung with rose-pink curtains, and astonishingly cheap. Within a few weeks, a housemaid sees something in an upstairs room that drives her out of her mind, and the friend’s letters begin to tremble. That is the setting for Rhoda Broughton’s “The Truth, the Whole Truth, and Nothing but the Truth,” first published in 1868, and it is the first story in my new reading series, Tales by Lamplight.




A story told in letters


The story consists entirely of six letters between two friends, Cecilia Montresor in London and Bessy De Wynt in Dover. The form was an old one by 1868, but Broughton uses it cleverly. Neither woman can see what the other sees. We learn about the house only as Cecilia chooses to tell it, in the chatty, breathless voice of a society woman in the middle of the season. The gossip about callers and hampers of flowers from the country makes the turn toward terror feel all the more real.


The letters are also full of small, convincing details of fashionable London life in the 1860s: house agents and the scramble for a house for the season, riding in Rotten Row, the Calais packet coming in at Dover, a cab sent for the doctor. Broughton knew the society she describes, which may be why it still feels so lived-in.


Rhoda Broughton


Rhoda Broughton was born near Denbigh, in North Wales, in 1840, the daughter of a clergyman. Her uncle by marriage was Sheridan Le Fanu, the Irish master of the ghost story, and he helped her into print. Her first two novels appeared in his Dublin University Magazine in 1867, and he introduced her to the publisher Richard Bentley.


Her early novels were thought daring. Heroines who spoke their minds and fell in love unwisely made her famous, and the circulating libraries made her a favorite. As literary tastes changed, the boldness that had once scandalized readers came to seem almost old-fashioned. She counted Henry James among her friends and spent her last years near Oxford, where she died in 1920.


The story and its readers


“The Truth, the Whole Truth, and Nothing but the Truth” first appeared in the magazine Temple Bar in February 1868. In 1873, Bentley collected it with four other supernatural stories in Tales for Christmas Eve, later reissued as Twilight Stories. It remains one of Broughton’s most memorable ghost stories.


What makes it so effective is what Broughton leaves out. We never see the thing in the room. Even in her lucid moments, the housemaid will not say what she saw. She only shudders and hides her face. We have only Cecilia’s account, the letters and the silence where an explanation ought to be.


The story also has an intriguing resemblance to the later accounts of 50 Berkeley Square, the supposedly haunted Mayfair house. An 1879 account in The Mayfair Magazine told of a maid driven mad after an encounter in an upstairs room. By then the house was well known as haunted, but the similarity between the two stories is striking.


And then there is that last line, set apart from the final letter:


“This is a true story.”


Keep the lamps low


You’ll find the full reading on the K.B. Hall Home YouTube channel in the Tales by Lamplight playlist. You can read the original text for free on Project Gutenberg, in Broughton’s Tales for Christmas Eve.


Keep the lamps low and the old stories close.


Watch




Sources

Broughton, Rhoda. "The Truth, the Whole Truth, and Nothing but the Truth." Temple Bar, February 1868.


Broughton, Rhoda. Tales for Christmas Eve. London: Richard Bentley and Son, 1873. Project Gutenberg eBook 69297.


Hadji, Robert S. "Rhoda Broughton." In Survey of Modern Fantasy Literature, edited by Frank N. Magill. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Salem Press, 1983.


Thomas, G. W. "Rhoda Broughton, Niece to Nightmares." gwthomas.org.


"50 Berkeley Square." The Mayfair Magazine, 1879.


Tales for Christmas Eve (1873), Project Gutenberg — original text, including all six letters and the final sentence.


At the Circulating Library: Tales for Christmas Eve — verifies the February 1868 magazine publication and 1873 collection.



Rhoda Broughton and Headington — additional biographical research and her Oxford years.

bottom of page